Research Compares Auto Insurance Policies for Good, Bad and Drunk Drivers: The $3,000 Dollar Difference

CHICAGO, Jan. 21, 2011 /PRNewswire/ — What’s the difference between a bad driving record and a good one? As much as $3,000 a year or more according to a new analysis comparing online auto insurance quotes. The research was conducted for Chicago-based online insurance resource E-Insure Services, Inc. Profiles were created for three fictitious drivers, all age 21 with 2009 Mustangs, living in Palatine, Illinois, and reporting the same five- to six-year history of previous car insurance coverage. The data that made the difference were their driving records.

“Everything else about the drivers’ profiles was as identical as possible using the various online applications of six major auto insurance companies,” said David Thompson, President and CEO of E-Insure Services. “Good Driver had no moving violations and no accidents, Bad Driver reported a couple of accidents, and Drunk Driver had a DUI conviction.”

Good Driver was able to get auto insurance quotes ranging from a low of $90.79 per month with to a high of $207.71 per month. Those same carriers quoted Bad Driver $166.22 per month and $238.05 per month, respectively. The real surprise was the wide discrepancy in policy prices for Drunk Driver. “One carrier wouldn’t insure Drunk Driver at all. Another wanted $347.86 per month. And a third gave Drunk Driver the low quote of $95 a month, almost as low as Good Driver’s lowest car insurance quote,” said Thompson.

Why such a range? In some cases, the fictitious drivers were able to get lower monthly quotes for by opting for the bare minimum state requirements for bodily injury and property damage, by declining optional coverage such as Uninsured Motorist Property Damage, by bumping up the deductible for comprehensive and collision, or eliminating it altogether. Passing on frills like rental car reimbursement and roadside assistance also shaved a few dollars from some of the car insurance quotes.

But tweaking coverage alone doesn’t explain the broad ranges. Thompson explained. “Car insurance companies look at a number of factors besides driving records to determine premiums. The miles you drive, your vehicle and its safety rating, even your credit score come into play. That’s why it really pays to get at least three competitive auto insurance quotes before you commit,” said Thompson.

Thompson noted that the policy prices have been going up. “A typical auto insurance policy is going to cost about $1,030 a year. That’s up almost 6 percent from last year. But there are ways to save money. Take advantage of auto policy discounts like anti-theft equipment, multi-car policies and using the same carrier for all your insurance coverage. Pay annually instead of monthly. Pay online at the insurer’s website. You should also review your auto insurance at least once a year and review your coverage options. If you’re insuring an older car, you might want to drop the collision and comprehensive and just keep the minimum liability coverage your state requires. If you’re shopping for a new car, research comparative insurance policy prices for different makes and models before you buy.”

About E-Insure?“?“??“????’?® Services, Inc.

E-Insure Services, Inc. provides a free online platform where consumers can easily find multiple insurance carriers and quotes for a variety of insurance products including auto insurance, business insurance, health insurance and home insurance. Specialty insurance products and financial services provider information are also available on the site. For the information and resources you need to get the best possible rates on auto insurance and other insurance products, for more information on auto insurance coverage options and to learn more about the auto insurance laws in your state, visit

David N. Thompson (312) 372-7400 [email protected]

E-Insure Services, Inc.

CONTACT: David N. Thompson,, +1-312-372-7400,[email protected]

Web Site: